User talk:Lirielle/MonsterCategories

Overall like this list. However I would like to propose some changes (in grammar as well as content).
 * Sewers Monsters --> Sewer Monsters -- sounds better, looks better, and follows the trend of keeping first part singular (these monsters are almost always the same in every sewer [this update may change that a bit]) (also first part singular --> city, forest, field)
 * Boowolf --> Boowolves -- i propose to keep the individual categories plural.
 * Other -- let's keep them separately under forest. we don't need categories like "other forest monsters".
 * Treechnidian -- i am pretty sure that this can be considered plural (ie. like sheep/sheep)
 * Kwak Villages Guardians -- i think villages should be singular. see note 1.
 * Bandits & Guards -- this is a tricky one. first, i don't understand what guards means (if you mean knights and militiamen then the following example suits). but, i definitely don't feel like the bandits should be on cania. they are most numerous on the bandits peninsula in amakna which is more foresty region. also, you are forgetting dark people. so, baring this in mind, i would create a new category called "humanoids" (i don't know if this should be under something, but it could also be a distinct category under habitats, because humanoids tend to live everywhere). under which would be:
 * Bandits
 * (City) Guards
 * Dark People (??)
 * Blop --> Blops -- see note 2
 * Dragoturkey --> Dragoturkeys -- see note 2
 * Scaraleaf --> Scaraleafs -- see note 2
 * Moor Monsters -- maybe just keep them inside that category as i proposed for other.
 * Cemetery Monsters -- doesn't work at all. half of them don't live in cemetaries. night monsters is also not very good (but i think still a bit better). wild monsters? evil monsters? don't know. (also you have swamp monsters twice under there)
 * Pandala Ghost --> Pandala Ghosts -- see note 2
 * Pandala Monsters (villages) -- would put all of these under Pandala Monsters and remove this stupid category
 * Kwismas Island Monsters -- would move this under geographical, because the island actually exists.
 * Additional groups -- would add "Event Monsters" (halloween, santa cloth minitoball) and "Retired Monsters" (dragoturkey, wild dragoturkey) [Maybe name this "Extinct Monsters" :)]

but even with this grouping i would place mushd under both sewer and swamp. gobkool under cave and gobballs. etc.--ilmarine 20:59, 1 February 2007 (UTC)